Wednesday, March 23, 2011

NOTE TO BCTF --- you are not the employer

I'm going to start by saying this blog will likely get some people ticked; however here goes.

Two decades of provincial negotiations with the BC Teachers Federation have resulted in only one collective agreement --- all others have been imposed. Many you reading this probably know why; for some reason or other the BC Teachers Federation doesn’t seem to understand they are not them employer!

Years ago I worked at a unionized open pit copper mine. The union bargaining committee were able to negotiate safety issues, wages, work hours, etc ... typical things that would be brought up / negotiated during bargaining in the public sector.

Teachers though??? Well they seem to think think they can negotiate how few days and hours they work --- how small class sizes should be – the pay they receive – where and when they work – and on and on it goes.




The BCTF needs to understand what everyone else in the workplace does; there are employers, and there are employees. As long as they are not breaking labour law and WCB regulations the employers basically make the rules -- and for those who are the employees, they accept the work place conditions and work with the employers to have change brought about that both party’s can agree to.

Just because teachers are government employees, and in a union, does not mean they have special powers and can hold parents, students, and the government to ransom.

A media release from the BCTF states:
With their current contract set to expire on June 30, 2011, teachers across BC now are in the first phase of an important round of bargaining to reach new collective agreements for the 41,000 members of the BC Teachers’ Federation.

We know there are obstacles and challenges ahead, but we are eager to participate in a constructive round of good-faith bargaining to reach a negotiated settlement that meets the needs of teachers and students alike,” said BCTF President Susan Lambert. “In doing so, both the union and the employer can help make BC’s fine public education system even better.”

And again the teachers union, as I have mentioned, are linking working conditions and students’ learning conditions, as part of their bargaining objectives. That indeed will be an obstacle -- and a challenge.

The BCTF has said in their polling that 89% of British Columbian's believe that new Premier Clark should ensure more co-operation with teachers and other education partners.   Co-operate YES -- capitulate -- NO.

Regardless, I'm pretty sure it was a fairly biased poll, and that most taxpayers will agree that administrators in the eduction system should be the ones who are in charge. The B.C. government cannot, and should not, dismiss public-sector wage restraints simply to reach a new collective agreement with public-school teachers.

Here's my suggestion --- send the BCTF a notice; we are the employers, you are the employees.

I'm Alan Forseth in Kamloops, and those are the thoughts of one conservative.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Alan, perhaps you had a bad experience in school,or you are just so tired of wishing you still worked for the unionized mining company of your youth. I,m not sure why the items you negotiated for at the mine are different than the items the BCTF has attempted to negotiate for years. Your first two paragraphs make no sense at all. Why don't you really tell us why you hate the BCTF. Being a conservative does not mean you must hate unions Alan. I would have hoped you were above such over simplistic cliches. What do you think of radio announcers?

Unknown said...

Dear "Anonymous"

I have simply presented my thoughts and ideas, you obviously do not agree with them, and I have no problem with that.

You are welcome to your opinion, as am I.

I don't hate anyone so not sure where your comment about hating the BCTF comes from; NOTHING I wrote in any way shows any indication of hate. I may not respect the tactics of the union, however that is my right.

As I noted in my post, I was at a mine and numerous things were negotiated at contract times -- nothing however that directly impacted the ability of the mine owner to operate.

As for the comment about radio announcers, you'll have to better explain what you mean.

I was on both sides of the microphone for years -- it was a great experience early on, however the more community station ended up in large corporate networks I found it no longer was a fit for me.

There are great people in radio -- there are average people in radio -- and there are bad; just like any other work place.